We hope you will agree with us when we say:
Knives can be your best friend as well as your worst enemy in the kitchen.
It all depends upon the knife you have and the brand you bought it from. Typically, cheap knives are believed to be duller and lose their edge quicker. This is why, if you are going to be investing in a knife for yourself, you might as well go for one that has premium pricing but will last you many years to come. In this Chicago cutlery vs Henckel’s article, we will be talking about and comparing Chicago cutlery and Henckels and ultimately deciding whether or not you should go for one or the other.
Chicago Cutlery Vs Henckels Comparison Chart 2022:
Here we have compiled a comparison chart for you to look at. We will be further describing every feature in this chart and justifying it in the article below. We have made this list for you to decide on which knife fits your needs and requirements more accurately:
|Information||Chicago Cutlery||J.A. Henckels|
|Where It's Made||China||Solingen, Germany|
|Number of Forged Knife Lines||3||6|
|Blade Material||High Carbon, Stainless Steel||High Carbon, Rust-Resistant Steel|
|Warranty||Lifetime Limited Warranty||Lifetime Limited Warranty|
|Designed With a Bolster and Tang||Depends On The Line||Yes|
|Cleaning||Hand Wash Only||Hand Wash Only|
|Edge Angle||13-Degree Angle Per Side||15-Degree Angle Per Side|
|Handle Material||Depends On The Line||Wood or Synthetic Material|
Build of the Blade:
The blade you are going to be wielding for many years to come needs to be just perfect for you. It needs to have durability, stability, sharpness, and edge retention to it. We are going to be taking a look at all these features and how they compare between the two brands.
Henckels uses X50CrMoV15 stainless steel to beautifully craft all of its blades. This is high-end steel that is only used by premium brands mainly in Germany, including the infamous Cutco and Wusthof. The X50CrMoV15 stainless steel contains a mixture of elements such as carbon, chromium, molybdenum, and vanadium. These ingredients have been carefully selected to make the knife stain resistant, extremely durable, and able to maintain and keep an edge for a long period of time. Henckels mainly makes their knives with stamped blades but also offer some collections featuring a forged blade. The collections named Classic, Forged Contour, Forged Premio, Forged Synergy, Forged Accent, and Graphite are all made out of a forged blade while the others feature a stamped blade.
Stamped blades are mainly looked down upon by manufacturers as they are thinner and rumored to be less durable under immense pressure. This is because the blade is not made out of a single sheet of material but rather joined together whereas forged blades are the complete opposite. However, stamped blades are actually not as bad as they may seem at first. The stamped blades are much thinner than forged ones which means they are sharper than forged. They are also more flexible and much cheaper than what you would get with a forged blade. The reason forged blades are expensive is that forging requires a heating process to form and bend the blade to its desired shape. This process is deemed extremely complex and labor-intensive hence making it very expensive.
Coming to another difference, the hardness of the stainless steel blade is essential to look at when purchasing a knife for yourself. The hardness is measured on a Rockwell Hardness Scale also known as the RHS. The RHS of an ideal blade is between 55 and 60. Henckels doesn’t hold back in this regard as they harden their blades to a whopping 57 on the Rockwell scale which is known as a sweet spot as it makes the knife not too thin as to affect its durability and it also doesn’t make the knife blade too dull as to not affect its sharpness.
Coming to the other side of the spectrum, when we talk about Chicago cutlery, their knives are made from high-carbon stainless steel. Although their exact formula is a secret, the company promises its customers that the knives won’t rust or pit for as long as they take proper care of it.
Chicago cutlery offers both forged and stamped blades much like Henckels depending on which collection you are planning to acquire. They have 11 different collections you can choose from. The Malden collection has a stainless steel shiny handle with a forged blade built to last. The Metropolitan collection has triple-riveted polymer handles that make them extremely comfortable and easy to wield. This collection features a stamped blade, however.
On the Rockwell Hardness Scale, the Chicago Cutlery brand offers a maximum hardness of 54/55 on all their knives. This means that their blades are not only ideal but also much thinner making them seem sharper than Henckels.
Read More: Cuisinart vs Calphalon
Sharpness Of The Blade:
In an in-depth JA Henckels knives review, it was found that Henckels Cutlery is sharpened at a 15-degree edge per side. On the other hand, Chicago Cutlery is much sharper at a 13-degree angle per side (26 degrees total). This is one of the sharpest blades you can find on the market internationally. However, this amount of sharpness on a blade does have a drawback to it. The 13 degrees edge makes the knife have a thinner blade, making it more likely to chip or break. This decreases the edge retention on the knife, which significantly lessens the lifetime of a knife. Nonetheless, Henckels knives are significantly duller than that of Chicago Cutlery so if you want a sharper blade, you should definitely go for Chicago Cutlery but if you require one that will last you a lifetime, Henckels is the way to go.
Here is a chart for you to look at in case you want to know how the prices compare for both the brands. This will help you make a better judgment on which product line you would like to purchase:
|Product Lines||Price||View on Amazon|
|Chicago Cutlery Insignia 2||💲💲💲|
|Chicago Cutlery Insignia Steel||💲💲|
|Chicago Cutlery Fusion||💲💲💲|
|Chicago Cutlery Belden||💲💲💲💲|
|Chicago Cutlery Essentials||💲|
|Chicago Cutlery Malden||💲💲💲|
|Chicago Cutlery Metropolitan||💲💲|
|Henckels Forged Premio||💲💲💲💲|
|Henckels Forged Contour||💲💲|
Handle Of The Blade:
The material used to craft Chicago Cutlery’s handles comes in various qualities and designs. For example, their Walnut Tradition collection uses Walnut wood as the name of the set suggests while the Metropolitan collection has polymer handles. Some other materials used by them for handles are soft-grip rubber or polished stainless steel. If you are looking for a range of choices when it comes to the handle of a blade, you have hit the jackpot with Chicago Cutlery as they offer a multitude of handle materials that are both comfortable and easy to use.
Henckel’s handles are made out of a durable and moisture-resistant plastic which is known as polyoxyethylene or POM. They go for a more western type style with three rivets on each side of the handle to keep the tang in place and provide extreme stability. Only two of the Henckels collections differ from this and use a stainless steel handle. These are known as the best knife sets for the money and are called the Modernist and Graphite collections. If you are looking for the best budget knife sets, these collections should definitely be two of the competitors.
Chicago Cutlery Review:
Chicago Cutlery has been producing and manufacturing consumer kitchen knives since 1969. Over the years, they have experimented, learned, and run one of the best business models in all of the cutlery industry. If you want a knife that is razor-sharp right out of the box or you want some options and designs to choose from, you should definitely consider Chicago Cutlery. These knives are not only comfortable to use but have some of the best budget knife sets and knives you can buy. These knives fall into two categories: They have well-forged blades within their fusion and Insignia II product lines, while they also have cheap and affordable knives that have been built from a stamped blade
Henckels Knives Review:
JA Henckels, also known as Henckels International is a part of the infamous Zwilling brand of knives. This may seem confusing, but Zwilling is basically the parent company that crafts a high-end version of the Henckels knives. Like Chicago Cutlery, Henckels has also experimented with their knives over the years and found what works for them. If you want a knife that will last you a lifetime with a good warranty, and a company to back it up, you should consider purchasing a Henckels knife. Their knives are crafted in Germany with extreme precision and are made for durability. They are a perfect blend of sharp and stable knives used by thousands of chefs around the world.
Hey there! i am Bobby Flay, an American celebrity chef, restaurateur, and reality television personality. I am the owner and executive chef of several restaurants across 11 states. And so, i’ve decided to share some of my expertise by reviewing and rating multiple different products and equipment i’ve used and loved over the years, so you at home, can get the best products by professional advise.